13 Differences in FRP & Polypropylene Tanks
Storage tanks are an integral part of any wastewater treatment infrastructure. They enhance the efficiency and reliability of treatment processes, contribute to environmental protection, and help ensure that treated wastewater meets the required standards before discharge. Two of the most widely used tanks in industrial wastewater treatment are the FRP and polypropylene tanks.
FRP (Fiberglass Reinforced Plastic) and polypropylene tanks are both used in wastewater treatment and other industrial applications, but they have distinct differences in terms of material composition, properties, and suitable applications.
This blog will dive deeper into what makes these two tanks different and where they are best used.
Material Composition:
We will first look at the different materials that are used in each tank. FRP tanks are constructed using a combination of fiberglass and a thermosetting resin, typically polyester or epoxy. The fiberglass provides structural strength, while the resin acts as a binder, holding the fibers together and providing resistance to chemicals and corrosion.
Polypropylene tanks are made entirely from polypropylene, a thermoplastic polymer known for its excellent chemical resistance and durability.
Construction:
The construction of FRP tanks usually involves processes such as filament winding, hand lay-up, or spray-up. These methods involve applying layers of fiberglass or other reinforcing materials with a resin matrix to create a composite structure. After the layers are applied, the composite materials are cured to harden and form the tank.
Polypropylene can be welded, allowing for the fabrication of complex tank designs and modifications. This flexibility in manufacturing can accommodate specific requirements.
Chemical Resistance:
FRP Tanks:
Chemical Resistance: FRP tanks are known for their excellent chemical resistance. They can withstand a wide range of corrosive chemicals, including acids, alkalis, and a variety of other aggressive substances. FRP tanks are commonly used in industries where chemical storage is a primary concern.
Fiberglass Barrier: The outer layer of the FRP tank is typically composed of a resin-rich barrier layer that provides an effective shield against chemical corrosion. This barrier layer is reinforced with fiberglass to enhance structural strength and corrosion resistance.
Laminates: The inner layer of FRP tanks can be customized with different types of resins and fiberglass laminates to optimize corrosion resistance for specific chemicals. Various resin choices are available, such as polyester, vinyl ester, or epoxy, each offering different levels of resistance to particular chemicals.
Structural Integrity: FRP tanks maintain their structural integrity even in harsh chemical environments. They do not corrode or weaken when exposed to corrosive substances, making them a durable choice for long-term use.
Polypropylene Tanks:
Chemical Resistance: Polypropylene tanks also exhibit good chemical resistance, particularly against a wide range of acids and alkalis. However, they may not be as versatile as FRP tanks when it comes to handling a broader spectrum of chemicals.
Thermoplastic Material: Polypropylene is a thermoplastic material that inherently resists chemical attack. Its molecular structure makes it highly resistant to many corrosive substances.
Temperature Limits: The corrosion resistance of polypropylene can be influenced by temperature. While it performs well with many chemicals at lower temperatures, its resistance may decrease at higher operating temperatures.
Welded Seams: Polypropylene tanks are typically fabricated using fusion welding to create leak-free seams. These welded seams maintain the tanks' integrity and resistance to chemical corrosion.
Corrosion Resistance:
FRP tanks are generally resistant to corrosion from various chemicals and industrial wastewater. However, they may not be as chemically resistant as polypropylene tanks in some aggressive environments.
Polypropylene tanks are highly corrosion-resistant and are well-suited for environments with harsh chemicals and corrosive wastewater.
Low Maintenance:
Due to their resistance to corrosion and chemical attack, FRP tanks and polypropylene tanks generally require less maintenance over their lifespan compared to metal tanks. This can result in cost savings over time.
Cost:
FRP Tanks:
Initial Cost: FRP tanks are typically more expensive to manufacture than polypropylene tanks. The cost of FRP tanks is influenced by factors such as the size, design complexity, and the type of resin used (polyester, vinyl ester, or epoxy).
Customization: If your application requires customized FRP tanks with specific design features, such as unique shapes or extra reinforcement, the cost can increase significantly.
Chemical Compatibility: When FRP tanks are needed for storing highly corrosive or hazardous chemicals, the additional cost for specialized resins and construction methods may be justified by the need for chemical resistance and safety.
Polypropylene Tanks:
Lower Initial Cost: Polypropylene tanks are generally less expensive to manufacture compared to FRP tanks. The cost advantage is particularly noticeable for standard-sized, non-customized tanks.
Modular Design: Many polypropylene tanks come in modular designs, which reduces manufacturing complexity and costs. These tanks can be assembled from pre-made components, saving on labor and fabrication expenses.
Chemical Resistance: While polypropylene tanks have good chemical resistance, they may not be suitable for as wide a range of chemicals as FRP tanks. However, for applications where polypropylene's resistance is sufficient, the lower initial cost may make them a cost-effective choice.
Mechanical Properties:
FRP tanks are known for their high strength-to-weight ratio, providing excellent structural integrity while remaining relatively lightweight.
Polypropylene tanks are also mechanically strong and can withstand pressure and external loads, but they may be heavier compared to FRP tanks of the same size.
Ease of Installation:
The lightweight nature of FRP tanks makes them easier to transport and install compared to heavier polypropylene or metal tanks, potentially reducing installation time and costs.
Fabrication and Design:
FRP tanks are often custom-fabricated and can be molded into various shapes and sizes to suit specific application requirements.
Polypropylene tanks are available in various standard sizes and shapes, and they are more suitable for applications where off-the-shelf solutions are sufficient.
Longevity:
When designed and installed correctly, FRP tanks and polypropylene tanks can have a long service life. They are often used in applications where long-term storage is required. When used correctly, it is not uncommon for the tanks to last several decades or more.
Environmental Considerations:
Polypropylene is generally more environmentally friendly in terms of recyclability and lower energy consumption during production. FRP tanks, on the other hand, are known for their durability and long lifespan, which can reduce the need for replacements.
Insulation Properties:
FRP Tanks:
Insulation Compatibility: FRP tanks can be insulated using various insulation materials, such as polyurethane foam, fiberglass insulation, or mineral wool. The choice of insulation material depends on the specific requirements of the tank and its contents.
Heat Retention: FRP tanks tend to have better heat retention properties compared to polypropylene. Therefore, insulating them is often done to minimize heat loss and maintain temperature levels for the contents.
Insulation Options: FRP tanks can be insulated using conventional insulation methods and materials commonly used for metal or plastic tanks. The insulation choices and methods for FRP tanks are diverse and depend on the specific needs of the application.
Polypropylene Tanks:
Insulation Compatibility: Polypropylene tanks can also be insulated using various insulation materials, similar to FRP tanks. The choice of insulation material depends on the specific requirements.
Maintenance of Chemical Temperature: Insulation of polypropylene tanks may be required to maintain the temperature of the chemicals being stored, especially in applications where temperature control is critical.
Non-Toxic and FDA Approved:
Polypropylene is a non-toxic material and is approved for use in applications where contact with food or beverages is involved. This makes it suitable for use in industries such as food and beverage, pharmaceuticals, and water treatment.
In summary, both FRP and polypropylene tanks have their advantages and are commonly used in wastewater treatment, chemical processing, and other industrial applications. The choice between the two depends on factors such as the specific chemical composition of the wastewater, the required chemical resistance, budget constraints, and the design and size requirements of the tank. It is essential to carefully evaluate the properties and suitability of each material for the intended application to ensure optimal performance and longevity.
J.Mark Systems
For decades, J.Mark Systems has become an expert in water treatment systems. With hundreds of installations under our belt, we have the experience you need to ensure that your water system is safe. You can trust our knowledge and rely on us for high-quality work in everything we do.
Every day, J.Mark Systems works with industrial water systems to ensure that your water is clean for use by everyone who has access to it. We provide treatment solutions via wastewater treatment, reverse osmosis, and various treatment technologies like multimedia filtration and membrane separation.
Do you need wastewater treatment for your industrial water system? We’re here for you, whether you know what you need or are looking for expert guidance. You can contact us to get started today! J.Mark Systems has the treatment solution you need for your industrial water system.